This is pretty slick and an awesome layout! I had this nearly EXACT idea for a Lasers & Feelings game at least a couple years after you but I had no idea this was out there already. I also have NO graphic design! skills Although, in order to make it more diametrically opposed, I was thinking of Poser (Low) & Punk (High).
My PUNK is exactly the same and my Poser is pretty darn close to PITCH included planning like yours (and presumably business acumen) but also Poser includes keeping the band afloat in $, supplies, roadies, and whatever else the band demands at the expense of watering down the PUNK. Now that I see your slick design, maybe I'll rework mine into more of a Honey Heist style game. Any thoughts? Any chance I could get you to do the layout?
In any case, I'd love to get a group together to give your game a spin. Nicely done!